Brazil's top court eases access to confidential information in criminal probes
Brazil’s police and prosecutors can access confidential tax and financial information without a court order, the country’s Supreme Court ruled on Thursday, clearing the way for authorities to reopen an investigation of the president’s son. A majority …
Prosecutors Usually Send People to Prison. These Are Getting Them Out.
After Aaron Salter was convicted of murdering a man he had never met, he immediately began trying to track down the real killer from behind bars. When another inmate described the crime in detail, Salter began investigating him. Eventually that other man signed an affidavit swearing that Salter was innocent.Yet appeals courts refused to grant him a new trial.Then, last year, his lawyers sent his file back to the Wayne County prosecutor in Detroit — the same office that had sent him away for life without parole in 2004. This time, the file landed in the hands of the office’s new conviction integrity unit, which determined that the case against Salter had been based on mistaken identification by the prosecution’s only witness.”Three months later, I was free,” Salter said.The unit that exonerated him is part of a major shift in the role of some of the nation’s district attorneys, who have traditionally focused on sending people to prison. Now, a growing number of prosecutors are also working to get wrongly convicted people out.Their efforts have provided an unflattering look at a system focused on winning convictions, sometimes with little apparent regard for a suspect’s actual guilt. In some instances, re-examining old cases has forced prosecutors to go up against their predecessors or their city’s police force, accusing them of wrongdoing or negligence.Almost 60 local prosecutors across the country have created special units like the one in Detroit to review questionable convictions, including the state’s attorney in Baltimore, Marilyn Mosby, who Monday persuaded a judge to exonerate three men convicted of murdering a fellow student when they were teenagers. They had spent 36 years behind bars.Half of these units are less than 4 years old, and the pace at which they are being created has accelerated in recent years, tracking an increase in reform-minded prosecutors winning election in mid-size and large cities.The units have helped clear almost 400 people over the past dozen years, and they helped win releases in more than a third of the 165 exonerations recorded in 2018, according to a national registry maintained by three universities. The exonerated were largely African American men convicted of crimes like murder, robbery and drug offenses. Their prosecutions were found in many cases to have been marred by perjury, false accusations or misconduct by police officers or prosecutors.Some of these units have proved far more effective than others. The unit run by Philadelphia District Attorney Larry Krasner, for example, has won release for 10 inmates during the past two years.Mosby has won exonerations for nine people since she took office in Baltimore in 2015 but not without criticism from some former prosecutors and police officers who consider it a rebuke of their work. A detective who worked on the case of the three men who were released this week accused her office of trying to make police “look like liars and cheats.”Although the release of the men might have cast doubt on the integrity of the criminal justice system, Mosby said, the mission of a prosecutor should be to seek justice.”What that means is that you have an ethical and a legal obligation as a prosecutor to ensure that you exonerate those that are wrongly accused, convicted and incarcerated,” Mosby said Tuesday.The unit in the Detroit prosecutor’s office that secured the release of Salter was established two years ago. It has helped free 11 people, including five who were determined to be innocent and six whose prosecutions were profoundly flawed.”The number of cases they have put together, at the pace they have done, is just extraordinary,” said Samuel Gross, a professor emeritus at the University of Michigan law school who helped establish the exonerations registry.The Wayne County unit is led by Valerie Newman, a former federal public defender. Newman said that her office had set out to rectify what she saw as a lack of prosecutorial accountability.”We’re not afraid to take a look at those mistakes and correct them if things have gone wrong,” she said.Her work has won over skeptics who doubted the sincerity of the office’s commitment.”After 20 years in the business, you get kind of jaded,” said Wolfgang Mueller, a lawyer in Detroit who is representing Salter in a civil suit. But Newman impressed him. “They have everybody talking to the old witnesses,” he said. “They have really brought fresh eyes to it.”Not every unit has such a strong track record. At least nine have been operating for three or more years without a single exoneration, according to data from the exonerations registry. Seven others have only one exoneration in that period.”For a fair number of offices, they are often no more than cosmetics,” said Rachel Barkow, a law professor at New York University who recently completed a term on the U.S. Sentencing Commission.Some law enforcement officials have questioned the very principle of reopening settled convictions and pushed back on efforts to free inmates. The prosecutor in Kansas City, Kansas, recently won funding for an integrity unit despite criticism from the local sheriff and police chief, who said that it would give the district attorney’s office “unchecked” power to revisit guilty verdicts.In many cases, these units are relying on groundwork laid by nonprofits like the Innocence Project and convicted prisoners themselves, who, like Salter, amassed significant evidence of their innocence but couldn’t get judges to listen.”Courts are not designed to investigate cases the way this unit is,” said Darrell Siggers, who spent 34 years in prison before Newman’s unit won his release last year. He was convicted based on erroneous testimony from a police officer who said that a bullet in the victim’s body matched one found in Siggers’ apartment building.Siggers was able to disprove that after a law professor at the University of Michigan helped him pay for his own ballistics analysis. Indeed, the firearms unit at the Detroit crime lab was so riddled with errors that it was shut down in 2008. Yet judges still refused to grant Siggers a new trial.”Courts are confined to procedural errors,” said Siggers, who now runs a company that helps prisoners file requests for public records about their cases. “But the conviction integrity’s unit’s main purpose is the truth.”This article originally appeared in The New York Times.(C) 2019 The New York Times Company
Spain's Socialists, Catalan separatists to continue talks on new government
Spain’s Socialists and Catalan separatist party Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya (ERC) said on Thursday they had “constructive dialogue” during their first official meeting to negotiate the formation of a new Spanish government. In a joint statement …
German central banker pushes back on calls for ECB to fight climate change
Bundesbank chief Jens Weidmann on Thursday batted back calls for the European Central Bank to take a bigger role in protecting the environment, saying it was up to governments and not the ECB to fight climate change. “Monetary policy that explicitly p…
Qatari foreign minister's Saudi visit seen easing Gulf rift
RIYADH/LONDON, Nov 28 (Reuters) – Qatar’s foreign minister has made an unannounced visit to Riyadh, two sources told Reuters, amid signs that a 2-1/2-year rift among U.S.-allied Gulf Arab states could soon subside. Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman al-T…
Dutch father who kept kids isolated for 9 years in a farmhouse, accused of sex abuse: Prosecutors
The father detained for holding six of his children against their will in a remote Dutch farmhouse for nine years is now suspected of sexually abusing two of his older children, according to Dutch prosecutors. “In addition to money laundering and depr…
German central banker pushes back on calls for ECB to fight climate change
Bundesbank chief Jens Weidmann on Thursday batted back calls for the European Central Bank to take a bigger role in protecting the environment, saying it was up to goverments and not the ECB to fight climate change. “Monetary policy that explicitly pu…
UPDATE 1-Facebook works to restore access after Thanksgiving Day outage
Facebook Inc said it was working to restore access on Thursday to its users after issues with its central software systems triggered an outage in its family of apps including Instagram on the busy Thanksgiving Day holiday. Facebook was hit by a major …
UPDATE 1-Trump makes surprise Afghan trip, voices hope for ceasefire
President Donald Trump made a surprise Thanksgiving visit to U.S. troops in Afghanistan on Thursday and said he believed Taliban insurgents would agree to a ceasefire in America’s longest war. Trump’s visit was his first to Afghanistan since becoming …
State-controlled lender Banco do Brasil sees 2020 profit up 10%
Brazilian state-controlled lender Banco do Brasil SA sees its profits likely growing 10% in 2020 from this year, its Chief Financial Officer Carlos Hamilton Araujo said on Thursday in a meeting with analysts. Banco do Brasil’s 2019 profit should reac…
EU parliament condemns Cuba's detention of top dissident
The European parliament joined the United States on Thursday in condemning Cuba’s detention and reported mistreatment of leading dissident Jose Daniel Ferrer, whom the Communist government in Havana calls a U.S.-backed counterrevolutionary. The move c…
Recent Comments